Usually reflecting a great sense of exhilaration and frustration, player evaluations of Geometry Dash regularly note both the addictive character of the game and its difficulty. Many gamers value the quick-paced, rhythm-based gameplay in which success depends on timing and accuracy. Though challenging to learn, the game's basic mechanics—managing a cube that leaps over several obstacles—are much appreciated for being clear-cut The game gets so much good comments mostly because of this harmony between simplicity and challenge. Many times, players find that the mix of expertly crafted levels and rhythmic tunes keeps them interested for hours.

On player reviews, the game's great degree of challenge is a two-edged blade, too. While some players appreciate the challenge and get satisfaction in conquering challenging stages, others voice annoyance with the game's difficulty spikes. The merciless character of the game, whereby even a minor error may cause a level to be restarted from the beginning, can induce repetitiveness. Some evaluations capture the conflict between the gratification of conquering challenging portions and the annoyance of several failures. This comments on the game's thin border between being fun and frustrating, and some players say it can cause burn-out.

Conversely, those that value Geometry Dash's creative side usually pay more attention to the game's community and customizing features. The level editor lets players design and distribute their own levels, therefore fostering a vibrant community of creators. Many evaluations note how the user-generated material keeps the game's replayability ever changing. This feature in Geometry Dash lets players explore unusual difficulties outside of the official levels and offers unlimited variation.